- Steven Gilbert
- November 3, 2026
- in Planning
Direct Indexing: Finding Opportunity Beneath the Market’s Returns
Index funds have transformed investing. Instead of trying to identify which individual companies will outperform, an investor can buy a single fund designed to track an index such as the S&P 500.
Direct indexing takes that same basic idea—owning a diversified portfolio designed to track an index—but changes how the investor owns it.
Rather than purchasing an S&P 500 ETF that holds the underlying companies for you, a direct indexing strategy purchases many or all of the individual stocks directly in your account.
At first glance, that may seem like an unnecessarily complicated way to accomplish essentially the same thing. Why own hundreds of stocks when one ETF can provide similar market exposure?
One of the most important answers is tax management.
An ETF Gives You One Investment. Direct Indexing Gives You Hundreds.
Suppose you want exposure to the S&P 500.
With a traditional index ETF, you might purchase shares of a fund that tracks the S&P 500. The fund owns hundreds of companies, but from your perspective, you own one security: the ETF.
With direct indexing, your account instead owns many of the individual stocks of the S&P 500 of the companies represented in the index.
Economically, the two portfolios may be designed to provide very similar exposure.
From a tax perspective, however, they can be quite different.
The S&P 500 Can Be Up While Many of Its Stocks Are Down
This distinction becomes easier to understand when we look underneath an index’s headline return.
The above illustration provides a useful real-world example. From September 10, 2025 to September 9, 2026, the S&P 500 had produced a one-year total return of approximately 19.5%.
That sounds like an exceptionally strong environment for stocks—and it was.
But the individual companies making up the index had dramatically different experiences.
Among the 499 constituents included in the illustration:
- 172 had negative one-year returns, despite the S&P 500 as a whole gaining approximately 19.5%.
- 103 were down more than 10%.
- 49 were down more than 20%.
- 21 were down more than 30%.
- Individual returns ranged from approximately -68% to +375%.
That dispersion is the key to understanding one of direct indexing’s primary potential advantages.
An index’s return is the combined result of hundreds of individual investments. Some companies can be producing tremendous gains at exactly the same time that other companies are experiencing significant losses.
When you own an ETF, most of that activity is hidden inside a single investment.
When you own the individual stocks, those gains and losses exist as individual positions in your account.
Why That Matters for Tax-Loss Harvesting
Consider a simplified example.
Suppose you invested $100,000 into an S&P 500 ETF and, over the following year, it increased by 19.5%.
Your investment would now be worth approximately $119,500.
You have a gain. There generally isn’t a loss in that ETF position available to harvest.
But imagine instead that the original $100,000 was invested through a direct indexing strategy.
The overall portfolio might still be worth approximately $119,500. But underneath that $19,500 net gain could be dozens—or potentially hundreds—of individual winners and losers.
For example:
| Position | Original Investment | Current Value | Gain/Loss |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stock A | $2,000 | $3,000 | +$1,000 |
| Stock B | $2,000 | $2,500 | +$500 |
| Stock C | $2,000 | $1,500 | -$500 |
| Stock D | $2,000 | $1,700 | -$300 |
| Other Holdings | $92,000 | $110,800 | +$18,800 |
| Total | $100,000 | $119,500 | +$19,500 |
The portfolio is up $19,500 overall, just like the ETF.
But Stocks C and D are individually sitting at losses.
A direct indexing strategy may be able to sell those positions, realize the losses for tax purposes, and reinvest the proceeds in other securities designed to maintain similar market exposure.
This is commonly referred to as tax-loss harvesting.
Capital losses can generally offset capital gains. If total capital losses exceed capital gains, individuals may generally deduct up to $3,000 of the remaining net capital loss against ordinary income ($1,500 for married taxpayers filing separately), with unused losses potentially carried into future years.
The objective isn’t to make the portfolio perform worse. It is to recognize losses that already exist inside the portfolio and potentially turn them into a tax asset.
These positional losses do happen in the ETF as well. You just can’t harvest them individually like you can with a direct indexing account.
One advantage over owning ETF’s is that you don’t necessarily need the market to be down to find investments that are down.
Direct Indexing Isn't Automatically Better Than an ETF
Despite its potential benefits, direct indexing isn’t the obvious choice for every investor.
Traditional index ETFs have some enormous advantages. They are inexpensive, easy to understand, easy to trade, highly diversified, and extremely simple to maintain.
Direct indexing introduces additional complexity.
Depending on the provider, investors may face higher management costs, hundreds of individual holdings, more complicated tax reporting, greater tracking differences from the benchmark, and additional coordination requirements when moving the portfolio to another custodian or investment strategy.
Most importantly, the potential tax benefits aren’t equally valuable to everyone.
An investor holding assets inside an IRA or other tax-deferred account generally doesn’t receive the same benefit from harvesting taxable investment losses because transactions inside the account generally aren’t currently reported as individual capital gains and losses.
Even in a taxable account, an investor with few capital gains and a large existing capital-loss carryforward may receive less immediate benefit than an investor who regularly realizes substantial taxable gains.
See Direct Indexing: Pros, Cons, and Strategies – Gilbert Wealth