Comparing Debt Payoff Strategies: Minimum Payment, Avalanche, and Snowball

Comments Off

When it comes to paying off debt, not all strategies are created equal — and not all minds are wired the same way. Some people are driven by logic and math; others by motivation and momentum. Understanding the differences between debt payoff strategies can help you choose the one that fits both your numbers and your mindset.

Let’s compare three common approaches: making only minimum payments, the debt avalanche, and the debt snowball.

Minimum Payments: The Bare Minimum

Lenders will calculate the minimum required payment for your outstanding balance. For loans like auto loans or mortgages, this is a fixed amount and is known up front. For revolving credit lines like credit cards or HELOC’s, this amount fluctuates based on the outstanding credit line.

Particularly for credit cards, paying the minimum only will result in you paying a lot more for the original expense over time.

If you owe $10,000 in credit card debt with a 20% interest rate and make only minimum payments, it could take decades to pay off — and you might pay more than double the original amount in interest.

Paying the minimum is useful if you are tight on cash due to a job loss as it prevents late fees and keeps accounts current but it’s not a long-term strategy.

The Debt Avalanche: Mathematically Optimal

The Debt Avalanche aims to pay off the highest interest rate debts first. Pay the minimum on all debts except the one with the highest rate — put every extra dollar toward that one until it’s gone, then move to the next.

Example:
If you have:

$6,000 Credit card at 22%
$3,000 Personal loan at 12%
$22,000 Car loan at 6%

List your debts by interest rate, from highest to lowest. You’d tackle the credit card first, then the personal loan, then the car.

As you’re tacking the highest interest rates first, mathematically you’ll pay the lowest over time to pay off all of your debts. However, progress can feel slow if those balances are also the largest.

The Debt Snowball: Momentum and Motivation

The Debt Snowball seeks to gain psychological momentum by paying off the smallest debts first to generate quick wins.

Pay the minimum on all debts except the smallest one — attack that first, regardless of interest rate. Once it’s gone, roll that freed-up payment to the next-smallest balance.

Example:
Assume the same numbers as above

$6,000 Credit card at 22%
$3,000 Personal loan at 12%
$22,000 Car loan at 6%

Using the Debt Snowball, you would tackle the personal loan first, the Credit Card second, and the car loan third.

Those who are motivated by progress and visible results. If seeing balances disappear keeps you going, the snowball’s behavioral advantage often outweighs its small mathematical disadvantage.

Which Debt Payment Strategy is the Best?

The best debt repayment strategy is the one that enables you to pay off the debt. Period.

While the Debt Avalanche is superior in terms to total outlay, if you give up on it because you aren’t seeing progress then it is an inferior strategy.

Paying off debt is less about perfection and more about persistence. Whether you’re an optimizer who thrives on numbers or a goal-getter who needs quick wins, what matters most is forward motion. Every payment brings you closer to freedom — and freedom is the real goal.

If you want to compare these strategies, check my calculator:

🧮Debt Reduction Calculator – Compare Debt Payoff Strategies – Gilbert Wealth